Republicans In Chaos (2026 Dec)

by Barry A. Liebling

The 2026 elections that just occurred are highly consequential. While it was generally expected that Democrats would do well, the magnitude and quality of their success is spectacular. They will now have a majority in both the Senate and the House of Representatives, and they are in a strong position to propose and pass a large number of laws that are on their agenda.

Consider the two main themes that define the spirit of the Democrat party. The first is that government must be expanded. Where the government is now supervising, regulating, or controlling aspects of American lives – the interventions must be increased. Where the government is absent it is essential that it becomes present. Allowing individuals to do whatever they want is dangerous, because they are liable to do the wrong thing (according to left progressive leaders). This applies to everyone’s personal life as well as to the world of business. So we need the government to intercede. Certainly, Democrats disagree with one another as to which government tinkering to prioritize, and exactly how policies should be implemented. But there is general agreement that the state should jump in.

The second theme is the strong desire to punish and aggress against people who are not part of their coterie. This can be mild as in cancelling or shunning those who do not enthusiastically conform to the the latest leftist fads. It can be moderate as in discriminating against individuals who are designated as belonging to any of several “oppressor” groups (white, straight, males are a favorite target). And it can be harsh where physical violence and even murder is cheered because the “oppressors” deserve it.

Note well that when Democrats scream “tax the rich” it is not really important what will be done with the confiscated riches. Their main objective is to steal, to take away, to push people down. When Democrats insist that wealthy people pay “their fair share” of taxes they mean that whatever the government is grabbing, it should scoop up more. Who are the rich? Voters are told it is anyone who has more than you. Who is exempt from harsh penalties? Wealthy people who promote the leftist progressive agenda.

So does this describe Democrats or Democratic Socialists? The distinctions that separate them are of degree but not of kind. The Democratic Socialists (elated with with recent victories) are eager and impatient to achieve their collectivist ends, but the “ordinary Democrats” prefer to go more slowly (and do not want to be exposed as socialists at heart).

Now consider the main message that Republicans are broadcasting to the world. It is, “we are not the Democrats.” In the past a lot of Republican officials would say they support free markets, limited government, and individual liberty. But this has changed. Yes, there are Republicans who appreciate and endorse the principles of freedom and are appropriately opposed to government abuse. But their influence in the party is diluted by a huge dominant contingent of “modern populism Republicans” who eschew free markets and push mercantilism where the government attempts to control which businesses will succeed. They are eager to help favored firms with subsidies and protect them with tariffs. And they are comfortable with the government purchasing equity stakes in companies that they regard as important, but they hope you do not recognize that this is pure socialism.

Note that the imposition of tariffs is an interesting case that deserves attention. For centuries tariffs have been recognized as a mercantilist attempt to help some firms succeed by making it more expensive to buy from foreign rivals. And to the extent that it benefits the government’s pets, it hurts citizens who are buyers because they have to pay more than they otherwise would. There is no question that tariffs are a leftist-interventionist policy.

So why have the Democrats come out strongly against tariffs? Because Trump initiated them, and to a perpetually enraged Democrat anything that Trump does (no matter what) is wrong and has to be opposed. It is likely that the new congress will do what it can to repeal Trump’s tariffs. Then when they accomplish this they will quietly bring back tarriffs to help the businesses that they favor.

Consider why citizens vote for Democrats or Republicans. A huge proportion cast their ballots out of habit. There are many Americans who are stuck and consider themselves a member of one of the parties. They do not spend time or effort thinking about the issues involved. They may or may not show up to cast ballots in a given election, but they are permanently loyal to one party.

Some citizens do look at the issues and decide how to vote according to what makes sense to them. Anyone who favors collectivism and government control should prefer the Democrats to the Republicans, because Democrats are consistent.

How should people vote who appreciate individual liberty? The Republicans have policies that are scattered and chaotic, and in the current political climate there is no telling what they will do next. The best that can be said for them is that sometimes (when?) they will act appropriately. That is a weak reason for voting Republican. Perhaps the party will improve.

*** See other entries at AlertMindPublishing.com in “Monthly Columns.” ***

Comments are closed.